Black-and-white development

Latent image to scan · ~11 min read

B&W is the one process you can genuinely do on a kitchen counter with a changing bag, a tank and three bottles. It’s also where your choices – which developer, how dilute, how long, how much agitation – visibly shape the negative.

A home darkroom with an enlarger, trays and safelight.

A home darkroom. Development itself needs only a daylight tank and a dark bag to load it; a full darkroom like this is for the printing stage. [Photo: Tatu Kosonen, CC BY-SA 4.0]

In short

  • Steps: develop → stop → fix → wash → (wetting agent) → dry.

  • Only development is critical on time/temperature; stop and fix are forgiving.

  • Developer families: general-purpose (D-76/ID-11, Xtol), one-shot liquids (HC-110, Ilfotec), high-acutance (Rodinal), fine-grain (Perceptol), speed-increasing (DD-X, Microphen), and monobath (develop+fix in one, e.g. Cinestill DF96).

  • Temperature 20 °C is the reference; time scales ~ ±factor per degree.

  • Agitation builds contrast and evenness; more = more contrast, less = compensating effects.

  • Look up times in a developer’s datasheet or the Massive Dev Chart.

The chemistry, step by step

Step

Time

Temp

Purpose

Pre-soak (optional)

1–3 min

match dev

even out temperature, swell emulsion, remove anti-halation dye (cleaner fixer). Some developers (Xtol) say skip it.

Developer

4–14 min (film/developer specific)

20 °C ±0.5 (or the stated temp)

the critical step. Converts exposed crystals to silver. Time/temp/agitation set contrast.

Stop bath

30–60 s

~20 °C

dilute acetic acid (or plain water × 2–3 changes). Halts development, protects fixer.

Fixer

2–5 min (rapid) / 5–10 min (older)

18–24 °C

dissolves undeveloped halide. Test with a clip test (a film leader clears in t seconds → fix for 2×t). Fixer is reusable; track capacity.

Wash

5–20 min

~20 °C

Ilford method: fill+invert 5×, dump; 10×; 20×. Or running water. Poor washing → brown stain and fading over years.

Hypo clear (optional)

1–2 min

~20 °C

cuts wash time and improves permanence, especially on fibre-base prints; nice for film too.

Wetting agent

30 s

~20 °C

a drop of Photo-Flo / Ilfotol in distilled water → no drying marks.

Dry

1–3 h

dust-free

hang weighted in a bathroom run hot for steam first (settles dust).

Everything after the developer can be done in room light once the film is in the tank. Loading the film onto the reel is the only true-darkness part (changing bag or dark room).

Temperature and time

20 °C (68 °F) is the classic reference. If your developer is warmer or cooler, adjust time. Rough guide (developer-dependent – use a real chart):

Temp

18 °C

20 °C

22 °C

24 °C

Time factor

×1.25

×1.00

×0.80

×0.65

Keep all baths within ~2 °C of each other to avoid reticulation (a cracked-mud grain pattern from thermal shock – rare with modern hardened emulsions but real). In summer, work at 24 °C with shorter times rather than fighting to cool everything to 20.

Agitation

Agitation replenishes developer at the emulsion and clears exhausted by-products.

  • Standard: invert the tank gently ~4 times per 30 s for the first 30 s, then 4 inversions every minute. Tap the tank to dislodge bubbles.

  • More agitation → more contrast, more even, slightly more grain.

  • Less / intermittent (“semi-stand”: agitate once at start and once at half-time) → lower contrast, strong edge effects (acutance), highlights that “compensate” (don’t run away). Risk: bromide drag – streaks below dense areas, especially off sprocket holes.

  • Stand development (Rodinal 1+100, 1 hour, agitate only at the start) → extreme compensation and sharpness, real risk of unevenness. A look, not a default.

Developer families

Developer

Type

Character & use

Kodak D-76 / Ilford ID-11

powder, general-purpose

The reference standard. Stock = balanced; 1+1 = sharper, finer grain, one- shot; 1+3 = sharper still. If you learn one developer, learn this. ~⅓ stop speed at 1+1.

Kodak Xtol / XDEV, Adox XT-3, Ilford Ilfotec DD-X

powder / liquid, fine-grain + speed

Modern ascorbate developer: finest grain and full box speed, very clean, great with T-grain films. Kodak now sells it as XDEV (5 L only); Adox XT-3 is a near-identical clone in smaller sizes. DD-X (Ilford, liquid) is similar and excellent for HP5/Delta and pushing.

Kodak HC-110 / Ilford Ilfotec HC / LC29

syrup/liquid concentrate

Long shelf life (HC-110 syrup lasts years), highly dilutable, one-shot, convenient. “Dilution B” (1+31) with Tri-X is a classic. Slightly more grain than D-76.

Rodinal / Adox Adonal / R09

liquid concentrate, high-acutance

Ancient (1891), nearly immortal shelf life, 1+25 to 1+100. Sharp, crisp edges, pronounced but tight grain. Superb on slow films (Pan F, FP4, Fomapan 100); harsh on fast films. The “grain and bite” developer.

Ilford Perceptol / Kodak Microdol-X

powder, extra-fine-grain

Solvent developer – smallest grain, at ~1 stop speed loss. For maximum smoothness on 100–400 films, or taming Tri-X.

Ilford Microphen / Kodak DK-50

powder, speed-increasing

Phenidone-based, buys ~⅔–1 stop. The push developer for HP5/Delta 3200.

Cinestill DF96 / Bellini Monobath / New55 R5

monobath (develop + fix in one)

One bath, one step, ~3–6 min, temperature-flexible (20–27 °C). Develops and fixes simultaneously. Dead easy, reusable ~16 rolls, slightly less control over contrast. The best “just get me a negative” option for beginners.

Caffenol (coffee + washing soda + vitamin C)

DIY

Genuinely works – a home-brew phenol developer. Grainy, characterful, cheap, smelly. A fun experiment, not an archival choice.

Two-bath (Diafine, Barry Thornton, D-23 divided)

powder, compensating

Bath A soaks in, Bath B activates. Time- and temperature-insensitive, automatic highlight compensation, one speed rating per film (Diafine rates Tri-X at ~1250).

Key idea

The developer is a second exposure decision. The same HP5 Plus negative, shot identically, is a different photograph in Perceptol (smooth, lower contrast, −1 stop) vs Rodinal (sharp, grainy, punchy) vs DD-X (clean, full speed). Pick the developer for the look, then the time for the contrast.

A first-timer’s recipe

Kit: changing bag, developing tank + reel, thermometer, 3 measuring cylinders, timer, 3 storage bottles.

  1. In the changing bag: open cassette (or use a leader retriever), trim leader, load film onto reel, into tank, lid on. Now you’re in daylight.

  2. Mix: developer (e.g. Ilfosol 3 1+9, or DF96 monobath) at 20 °C.

  3. Develop: pour in, start timer, agitate 30 s, then 4 inversions/min. (DF96: agitate first minute continuously, then 10 s/min, ~4 min.)

  4. Stop: water rinse ×3 (or stop bath 30 s). (Skip if monobath.)

  5. Fix: rapid fixer 3–5 min, agitate first 30 s then occasionally. (Skip if monobath – it fixed as it developed.)

  6. Wash: Ilford method (5/10/20 inversions) or 10 min running water.

  7. Rinse in wetting agent 30 s.

  8. Hang to dry 1–2 h, then cut into strips of 5–6 and sleeve.

Troubleshooting

Symptom

Likely cause

Thin, low-contrast negatives

underdeveloped (time/temp low), exhausted developer, or underexposed

Dense, hard-to-scan negatives, blown highlights

overdeveloped, or overexposed, or agitation too vigorous

Clear film, no images at all

fixed before developing / developer was actually fixer / no exposure (camera fault)

Milky / cloudy base

underfixed or exhausted fixer – refix in fresh fixer, rewash

Streaks below sprocket holes / dense areas

bromide drag – too little agitation with an active developer

Cracked-mud grain texture

reticulation – large temperature jump between baths

Drying marks / spots

no wetting agent, or hard water – final rinse in distilled water + Photo-Flo

Crescent-moon marks

film kinked while loading the reel

Where to go next