Black-and-white film

Types of film · ~9 min read

Black-and-white is the oldest and simplest film family: one emulsion, a silver image, process it yourself in a kitchen if you like. It is also where you have the most control – developer choice, dilution, time and agitation all visibly change the result.

In short

  • The final image is metallic silver in gelatin – genuinely archival for centuries if washed properly.

  • Two sub-families: traditional silver (develop in any B&W developer) and chromogenic (Ilford XP2 Super – runs in C-41 colour chemistry, dye image).

  • Grain structure splits into cubic (Tri-X, HP5+, Fomapan – chunky, forgiving) and tabular/T-grain (T-Max, Delta – finer, sharper, fussier).

  • You choose a B&W film for its speed, grain, tonal curve, and how it responds to pushing – then the developer is a second, equally large, creative choice.

What “black-and-white” actually varies

Since there is no colour to tune, designers work with:

Lever

Consequence

Speed (ISO 25 → 3200)

Grain and sharpness trade against low-light ability. ISO 100 and 400 are the workhorses.

Grain type (cubic vs tabular)

Cubic = organic, rounded grain, very push-friendly. Tabular = tighter, more clinical grain, more resolution, less push latitude.

Curve shape

Long-toe films (Tri-X) give gentle, rolling shadows; short-toe films (T-Max, Delta) give crisp blacks and higher acutance.

Spectral response

Most are panchromatic; a few are orthochromatic (Ilford Ortho Plus, Rollei Ortho 25) for a heavier-skies, red-blind vintage look.

Base

Nearly all 35 mm B&W film (Ilford, Kodak, Foma) is on acetate; polyester turns up in aerial-derived films (Rollei Retro/Superpan, JCH StreetPan) and a few specialist stocks (Rollei Infrared, CineStill BwXX).

Traditional silver films, by feel

Speeds are nominal ISO; “look” is a broad-strokes summary – developer changes all of it.

Film

ISO

Grain

Signature

Ilford Pan F Plus

50

Extremely fine

Glassy, high micro-contrast, deep blacks. Poor latitude, fades latent image fast – develop soon after shooting.

Kodak T-Max 100
(= Ektapan 100)

100

Extremely fine (tabular)

Clinical sharpness, straight curve, huge tonal range. The “technical” 100.

Ilford Delta 100

100

Extremely fine (tabular)

Slightly warmer/smoother rendering than T-Max, still very sharp.

Ilford FP4 Plus

125

Fine (cubic)

The classic “gentle” medium-speed film – forgiving latitude, beautiful mid-tone roll-off, loves most developers. A safe default.

Fomapan 100 Classic

100 (meter ~64)

Moderate (cubic)

Old-school look, prominent-ish grain for the speed, cheap. Rate slower for best shadows.

Kentmere Pan 100 / 400

100 / 400

Moderate

Harman’s budget line. Honest, slightly higher-contrast, no frills. Great value.

Kodak Tri-X 400

400

Moderate–coarse (cubic)

The documentary film. Grippy grain, strong blacks, gorgeous push response to 1600–3200. Endlessly reformulated but keeps its character.

Ilford HP5 Plus

400

Moderate (cubic)

Flatter and more malleable than Tri-X – enormous latitude, pushes to 3200, “you decide the contrast in development.” The other documentary standard.

Kodak T-Max 400

400

Fine (tabular)

The finest-grained true 400 B&W film. Sharp, modern, less “classic”.

Ilford Delta 400

400

Fine (tabular)

Tabular 400 with a slightly gentler curve than T-Max.

Ilford Delta 3200 / Kodak T-Max P3200

measured ISO ~1000 / ~800; sold as 3200

Coarse

Films whose real ISO is ~800–1000, engineered to be rated fast and pushed. Huge grain, dramatic contrast, the classic available-darkness look.

Fomapan 400 Action

400 (meter ~250)

Coarse

Grainy, characterful, inexpensive. Wide but “vintage” tonality.

Fun fact

Tri-X and HP5 Plus are two of the most-developed film emulsions in history. Tri-X in 35 mm dates to 1954, the original HP5 to 1976 (HP5 Plus in 1989); both have been quietly reformulated several times (Tri-X notably in 2007), and both survive because press and street photographers built their entire visual language around them. If a scene in a black-and-white photo essay from the last 60 years looks “right”, there’s a good chance it was shot on one of these two or on their predecessors.

Chromogenic B&W: Ilford XP2 Super

A B&W picture made with colour chemistry:

  • Develops in C-41 at any minilab – no B&W darkroom needed.

  • Image is dye, not silver → very fine, smooth grain.

  • Latitude EI 50–800 on a single roll, and grain gets finer with more exposure (opposite to silver film).

  • Scans beautifully; prints on colour (RA-4) paper with a slight warm/cool tint, or on B&W paper with reduced contrast control.

  • Downside: dye image is less archivally stable than silver, and it can’t exploit a true variable-contrast B&W printing workflow.

Kodak’s equivalents (BW400CN, Portra-era T400CN) are discontinued; XP2 Super is the last one standing.

Orthochromatic and other spectral variants

  • Ilford Ortho Plus 80 / Rollei Ortho 25 Plus – red-blind. Skies and lips go dark, skin turns contrasty and “vintage-portrait”. Can be tray-developed under a deep-red safelight.

  • Ilford SFX 200 – “extended red” (to ~740 nm). With a deep-red filter it does a gentle infrared-style effect (lighter foliage, darker skies) without a true IR film’s handling problems.

  • Rollei Infrared 400 / Rollei Retro 80S / 400S – genuine near-IR sensitivity on a polyester base; needs an IR filter (e.g. R72) and focus compensation for the full “Wood effect”.

See Spectral sensitivity: what colours the film can see and Specialty and oddball films.

Choosing a B&W film – a shortcut

You want…

Try

One film to learn on, forgiving

HP5 Plus or FP4 Plus in ID-11/D-76 1+1

Maximum sharpness & tonal range, tripod

T-Max 100 or Delta 100

Classic gritty reportage / street

Tri-X 400 (or HP5+ pushed to 800)

Available darkness, concerts

Delta 3200 or T-Max P3200 at EI 1600–3200

Cheapest usable film

Kentmere Pan 400 or Fomapan 400

No darkroom, 1-hour lab, smoothest grain

XP2 Super

Vintage look, red-blind

Ilford Ortho Plus

Where to go next