Black-and-white film¶
Black-and-white is the oldest and simplest film family: one emulsion, a silver image, process it yourself in a kitchen if you like. It is also where you have the most control – developer choice, dilution, time and agitation all visibly change the result.
In short
The final image is metallic silver in gelatin – genuinely archival for centuries if washed properly.
Two sub-families: traditional silver (develop in any B&W developer) and chromogenic (Ilford XP2 Super – runs in C-41 colour chemistry, dye image).
Grain structure splits into cubic (Tri-X, HP5+, Fomapan – chunky, forgiving) and tabular/T-grain (T-Max, Delta – finer, sharper, fussier).
You choose a B&W film for its speed, grain, tonal curve, and how it responds to pushing – then the developer is a second, equally large, creative choice.
What “black-and-white” actually varies¶
Since there is no colour to tune, designers work with:
Lever |
Consequence |
|---|---|
Speed (ISO 25 → 3200) |
Grain and sharpness trade against low-light ability. ISO 100 and 400 are the workhorses. |
Grain type (cubic vs tabular) |
Cubic = organic, rounded grain, very push-friendly. Tabular = tighter, more clinical grain, more resolution, less push latitude. |
Curve shape |
Long-toe films (Tri-X) give gentle, rolling shadows; short-toe films (T-Max, Delta) give crisp blacks and higher acutance. |
Spectral response |
Most are panchromatic; a few are orthochromatic (Ilford Ortho Plus, Rollei Ortho 25) for a heavier-skies, red-blind vintage look. |
Base |
Nearly all 35 mm B&W film (Ilford, Kodak, Foma) is on acetate; polyester turns up in aerial-derived films (Rollei Retro/Superpan, JCH StreetPan) and a few specialist stocks (Rollei Infrared, CineStill BwXX). |
Traditional silver films, by feel¶
Speeds are nominal ISO; “look” is a broad-strokes summary – developer changes all of it.
Film |
ISO |
Grain |
Signature |
|---|---|---|---|
Ilford Pan F Plus |
50 |
Extremely fine |
Glassy, high micro-contrast, deep blacks. Poor latitude, fades latent image fast – develop soon after shooting. |
Kodak T-Max 100
|
100 |
Extremely fine (tabular) |
Clinical sharpness, straight curve, huge tonal range. The “technical” 100. |
Ilford Delta 100 |
100 |
Extremely fine (tabular) |
Slightly warmer/smoother rendering than T-Max, still very sharp. |
Ilford FP4 Plus |
125 |
Fine (cubic) |
The classic “gentle” medium-speed film – forgiving latitude, beautiful mid-tone roll-off, loves most developers. A safe default. |
Fomapan 100 Classic |
100 (meter ~64) |
Moderate (cubic) |
Old-school look, prominent-ish grain for the speed, cheap. Rate slower for best shadows. |
Kentmere Pan 100 / 400 |
100 / 400 |
Moderate |
Harman’s budget line. Honest, slightly higher-contrast, no frills. Great value. |
Kodak Tri-X 400 |
400 |
Moderate–coarse (cubic) |
The documentary film. Grippy grain, strong blacks, gorgeous push response to 1600–3200. Endlessly reformulated but keeps its character. |
Ilford HP5 Plus |
400 |
Moderate (cubic) |
Flatter and more malleable than Tri-X – enormous latitude, pushes to 3200, “you decide the contrast in development.” The other documentary standard. |
Kodak T-Max 400 |
400 |
Fine (tabular) |
The finest-grained true 400 B&W film. Sharp, modern, less “classic”. |
Ilford Delta 400 |
400 |
Fine (tabular) |
Tabular 400 with a slightly gentler curve than T-Max. |
Ilford Delta 3200 / Kodak T-Max P3200 |
measured ISO ~1000 / ~800; sold as 3200 |
Coarse |
Films whose real ISO is ~800–1000, engineered to be rated fast and pushed. Huge grain, dramatic contrast, the classic available-darkness look. |
Fomapan 400 Action |
400 (meter ~250) |
Coarse |
Grainy, characterful, inexpensive. Wide but “vintage” tonality. |
Fun fact
Tri-X and HP5 Plus are two of the most-developed film emulsions in history. Tri-X in 35 mm dates to 1954, the original HP5 to 1976 (HP5 Plus in 1989); both have been quietly reformulated several times (Tri-X notably in 2007), and both survive because press and street photographers built their entire visual language around them. If a scene in a black-and-white photo essay from the last 60 years looks “right”, there’s a good chance it was shot on one of these two or on their predecessors.
Chromogenic B&W: Ilford XP2 Super¶
A B&W picture made with colour chemistry:
Develops in C-41 at any minilab – no B&W darkroom needed.
Image is dye, not silver → very fine, smooth grain.
Latitude EI 50–800 on a single roll, and grain gets finer with more exposure (opposite to silver film).
Scans beautifully; prints on colour (RA-4) paper with a slight warm/cool tint, or on B&W paper with reduced contrast control.
Downside: dye image is less archivally stable than silver, and it can’t exploit a true variable-contrast B&W printing workflow.
Kodak’s equivalents (BW400CN, Portra-era T400CN) are discontinued; XP2 Super is the last one standing.
Orthochromatic and other spectral variants¶
Ilford Ortho Plus 80 / Rollei Ortho 25 Plus – red-blind. Skies and lips go dark, skin turns contrasty and “vintage-portrait”. Can be tray-developed under a deep-red safelight.
Ilford SFX 200 – “extended red” (to ~740 nm). With a deep-red filter it does a gentle infrared-style effect (lighter foliage, darker skies) without a true IR film’s handling problems.
Rollei Infrared 400 / Rollei Retro 80S / 400S – genuine near-IR sensitivity on a polyester base; needs an IR filter (e.g. R72) and focus compensation for the full “Wood effect”.
See Spectral sensitivity: what colours the film can see and Specialty and oddball films.
Choosing a B&W film – a shortcut¶
You want… |
Try |
|---|---|
One film to learn on, forgiving |
HP5 Plus or FP4 Plus in ID-11/D-76 1+1 |
Maximum sharpness & tonal range, tripod |
T-Max 100 or Delta 100 |
Classic gritty reportage / street |
Tri-X 400 (or HP5+ pushed to 800) |
Available darkness, concerts |
Delta 3200 or T-Max P3200 at EI 1600–3200 |
Cheapest usable film |
Kentmere Pan 400 or Fomapan 400 |
No darkroom, 1-hour lab, smoothest grain |
XP2 Super |
Vintage look, red-blind |
Ilford Ortho Plus |
Where to go next
Black-and-white development – the developer half of the decision.
Black-and-white films, profiled – full profiles with datasheet numbers.
Filters for film – coloured filters to control B&W tonality.